0

Is there any way to test whether people were capable of doing things in those days that they cannot do today. One way (I'm sure there are others) to test would be to see if there are lots of reports citing similar occurrences in different places and at different times in front of a large number of people.

Even in medieval times, people referred to dybbuks etc. Again, the question is whether there are lots of reports of these things appearing in public. To sum up, has someone has scientifically investigated the possibility that the ancients could do things that we would call magical.

  • 2
    Magic and miracles is the bread and butter of mythologies... You really think that chroos could swallow his children and later spit them out alive? That Athena could go out of Zeus's head after he took an axe in the cranium? Magical features are referred in all myths. Could they perform the so-called magical treats.Some books make such claims, books by scientists with PhD. So the answer is 'yes' according to certain well selected sources. – Gibet Dec 26 '19 at 14:16
  • 2
    "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic." - Arthur C. Clarke – Spencer Dec 26 '19 at 17:34
  • Welcome to SE:Mythology. I've edited the title to be more suitable for this stack, and answered the question with some famous examples. – DukeZhou Dec 26 '19 at 19:47
2

This typically falls under the field of pseudo-science, although there have been rigorous, empirical attempts to validate the supernatural (all have failed.) However, these inquiries themselves have formed a type of modern mythology.

Some highlights:

  • Franz Mesmer (1734-1815) was a doctor who used a form of scientific method in an attempt to confirm a form of natural energy that connects living beings. Initially called "animal magnetism", his theories led to what we today call hypnosis (aka "mesmerism").

  • Wilhelm Reich was a doctor who investigated the paranormal. He is most famous for the concept of "orgone", a type of cosmic/biological energy. (His ideas may have provided a basis for "the Force" of Star Wars fame.)

  • Project MKUltra was an actual CIA research project that explored the possibility of scientific means of mind control, which appears in many mythologies. This endeavor has been subsequently popularized and extended in popular media.

  • Remote Viewing, a means of seeing things in distant locations, and even in the past, was studied, initially within the Spiritualist movement, but later by the CIA, the British government, and and the PEAR project at Princeton. Although none of these studies were a success, an early 19th century researcher includes Michael Faraday, who made significant contributions to the field of electromagnetism & chemistry.

Remote Viewing was a subject of the hit television series, Stranger Things and the film The Men Who Stare at Goats.

  • Isaac Newton, one of the most important & influential scientists in human history was an occult researcher.

As with Faraday, the boundaries of hard science were still being defined. The mystical art of alchemy likely provides some precursor to modern science & empiricism, chiefly chemistry, medicine & psychology. (A chief goal of alchemists was converting "lead into gold".) Similarly, numerology can be seen as a precursor to number theory and the modern predictive sciences, which utilize statistics (manipulation & analysis of numbers) to chart the path of planets and achieve reproducible results in all sciences. Before the term "scientists", those making inquiries into the sources of natural phenomena were often referred to as "Natural Philosophers".

Other examples can be found in the paranormal wiki. It also has to be mentioned that the debunkers of paranormal claims are often more famous than the promoters, chief among them Harry Houdini. In the contemporary era, this tradition has been carried on by the Amazing Randi and Penn & Teller.

| improve this answer | |
  • Thanks for this. I've posted a follow up question. – AlHal Dec 28 '19 at 20:43

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.