13

An important point in the story of the Iliad is that Odysseus (hoping to win the hand of Penelope, King Tyndareus niece), proposes an "Oath of Tyndareus", which binds all the suitors of Helen to join one another if one of the suitors abducts her after she marries one.

That Oath was what provided the legal pretext for the whole of Trojan expedition.

It also provided the reason for Odysseus to be sent to Troy (resulting in both the fall of Troy and the "Odyssey"), for he was one of the suitors of Helen! (and he clearly had no wish to go, as evidenced by attempt to fake insanity when summoned).

If Odyssey actually wanted to marry Penelope and not Helen, why was he even among the suitors of Helen in the first place?

First, it seemed entirely useless to him. He could have proposed the Oath without being a Suitor.

Second, that roped him into the whole adventure, and he should have been wily enough to realize it was the risk.

2
  • That may be an important point in the myth of the Trojan War, but it does not come up in the Iliad. See Richmond Lattimore's introduction to his translation (for which purpose you may have to seek out an older printing) on how utterly the poem neglects back-story. Nov 11, 2021 at 12:36
  • Also, separate myths have come down to us regarding the recruitment to the war effort of both Odysseus (outfoxed by Palamedes) and Achilles (outfoxed by Odysseus), while the oath of Tyndareus suffices to account for the participation of the other Achaean chieftains; and this suggests that these two were not parties to the oath. (Achilles was yet too young to be Helen's suitor at that time.) Nov 11, 2021 at 12:47

1 Answer 1

12

Odysseus was interested in marrying Helen, but he knew he wasn't a favourite amongst the suitors, and had anticipated that Helen would pick Menelaus, if given the choice:

And from Ithaca the sacred might of Odysseus, Laertes son, who knew many-fashioned wiles, sought her to wife. He never sent gifts for the sake of the neat-ankled maid, for he knew in his heart that golden-haired Menelaus would win, since he was greatest of the Achaeans in possessions and was ever sending messages to horse-taming Castor and prize-winning Polydeuces.

Source: Hesiod, Catalogue of Women

Not wanting to leave Sparta empty handed, Odysseus devised the Oath which allowed Helen to choose her favourite, and him to marry Penelope. At this point in time, the Oath was a pretty smart plan; all major players got what they wanted, without conflict. Of course the plan wasn't foolproof and it did backfire eventually, but we can't really blame Odysseus for failing to predict Paris would cross paths with Helen a decade later.

Lastly, I think it's interesting to note that the Oath's actual power is questionable:

And to me it seemeth that Agamemnon got together that fleet, not so much for that he had with him the suitors of Helen bound thereto by oath to Tindareus as for this, that he exceeded the rest in power.

Source: Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War, Book 1, chapter 9

Odysseus probably wouldn't have a choice, even if he wasn't bound by the Oath. It wasn't only the suitors that followed Agamemnon after all, the prime example of a non suitor that made it to Troy being Achilles.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.